Police officers can’t stop you for suspected DWI without a valid reason. They need reasonable suspicion to legally pull you over. If they stop you without it, they violate your Constitutional rights and the court could throw out any evidence police gather from the stop. If police stopped you illegally, you have the right to challenge your DWI charges and seek their dismissal. An experienced DWI defense attorney can help.
What is reasonable suspicion?
Many people have heard of probable cause, but reasonable suspicion is a different legal standard. Probable cause allows police to make an arrest or search your vehicle, but reasonable suspicion is what they need to stop you in the first place.
An officer establishes reasonable suspicion by pointing to specific facts and circumstances that would lead an objective person to believe someone has broken or is about to break the law. Police can’t pull you over based on a hunch or gut feeling. They must observe behaviors that suggest illegal activity and be able to explain why they believed stopping you was justified. In other words, officers need clear reasons to suspect you of a crime before they stop your vehicle.
Do police need reasonable suspicion during no-refusal weekends?
Texas uses no-refusal weekends to crack down on drunk driving during high-risk times, such as holidays and special events. During these weekends, officers have streamlined access to warrants that allow them to collect breath or blood samples from suspected drunk drivers. However, the rules don’t change when it comes to pulling you over.
Even during no-refusal weekends, police must have reasonable suspicion to stop you. They can't pull you over just because it’s a high-risk weekend or because you’re leaving a bar. They must observe specific behaviors that suggest you might be driving under the influence.
What driving behaviors can create reasonable suspicion for DWI?
Certain driving behaviors can give police officers reasonable suspicion. Some of the most common reasons officers pull drivers over for suspected DWI include:
- Speeding: Even slightly exceeding the speed limit violates the law and can justify a traffic stop.
- Failing to stay in your lane: Weaving, drifting, or struggling to stay within your lane often raises suspicion of intoxication. Frequent lane changes or hitting lane markers repeatedly could initiate a stop.
- Driving against traffic: Wrong-way driving is a serious red flag and often suggests impairment.
- Driving too slowly: While driving below the speed limit isn’t always illegal, consistently driving far under the limit can suggest impaired judgment or intoxication.
- Running red lights or stop signs: Traffic violations, especially at intersections, can give officers enough reason to stop you.
- Narrowly avoiding accidents: If you nearly hit another car or object, officers may suspect you're driving under the influence.
- Frequent braking: Excessive braking without cause can raise suspicions among law enforcement.
- Illegal turns: Making a U-turn where it’s not allowed or turning without signaling can justify a stop.
- Vehicle issues: Faulty headlights, a broken taillight, or an expired registration can also provide a reason for police to pull you over.
What happens if police stop you without reasonable suspicion?
If an officer pulls you over without a valid reason, the stop violates your Constitutional rights. In Texas, any arrest or criminal charges that result from an illegal stop could be dismissed. When police violate your rights, your lawyer can challenge the traffic stop and argue that any evidence gathered afterward is inadmissible in court. Without key evidence, the prosecution often struggles to prove the charges against you.
When police conduct an illegal traffic stop, any evidence they gather as a result could be excluded under the exclusionary rule. This rule prevents the state from benefiting from Constitutional violations. If police stopped you without reasonable suspicion, an experienced Texas DWI lawyer can file a motion to suppress evidence such as:
- Breathalyzer results
- Blood test results
- Field sobriety test results
- Officer observations and statements
Can DWI charges be dismissed?
The state must prove your guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, which becomes difficult when the judge throws out key evidence. If your lawyer successfully challenges the stop, the prosecution may have to drop the case due to insufficient evidence. Even if they try to move forward, the judge can dismiss the charges because the evidence against you was obtained illegally.
What should I do if I was stopped without reasonable suspicion?
If you believe police pulled you over without a valid reason, you should act quickly to protect your rights. Contact an experienced Texas DWI defense lawyer who can review your case and determine if your Constitutional rights were violated.
Attorney Amanda Webb can investigate whether police had reasonable suspicion to stop you, file motions to suppress illegally obtained evidence and challenge the prosecution's case to work toward a dismissal.
Even if the officer had reasonable suspicion, Attorney Webb can fight your charges by checking for improper calibration or blood sample handling, as well as any medical conditions you have that might be mistaken for alcohol impairment.
To protect your freedom and your future, reach out to Amanda Webb - DWI Lawyer today by filling out our online contact form or calling our law office in Conroe. We offer free DWI case reviews, so you can ask questions, learn about your legal options, and decide if our law firm is the best fit for your situation.
"Amanda Webb does awesome work. Professional and very good. She got me my life back!" — Ben, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐